We can all agree that Italian cuisine is deliscious – and you can’t really have one specific favourite dish, you love all of them, right? Well, our team is a huge Italian food lover as well – just like you, and we enjoy going out to different restaurants in hopes of finding places where they cook just like in Italy!

Thankfully, there are plenty of amazing Italian restaurants in Sutton that will make you feel like you are in Italy – and we wanted to share our favourite ones with you!

Top 4 Italian Restaurants In Sutton According To Our Team!


Casa Nostra Restaurant

Casa Nostra Restaurant is an incredible Italian restaurant with a simple decor that reminds us of restaurants in Italy. Their menu is focused on traditional pasta and pizza.

We highly recommend ordering their Penne Primavera (with peas, beans, broccoli spinach, tomato sauce, chilli, onions), their Vongole Spaghetti (with fresh clams, garlic, tomato sauce), or their Della nonna Risotto (chicken, fresh cream, mushrooms, asparagus, rocket leaves and parmesan). Also, all pizzas they offer are incredible!

We also want to focus on their desserts because they are super tasty and you definitely need to order one. If you love cheesecake, they have “homemade cheesecake of the day” so every day, they make a different flavour.

Address: 8 Mulgrave Rd, Sutton SM2 6LE


Spaghetti Tree Sutton

Spaghetti Tree Sutton is one of our favourite Italian restaurant in Sutton due to the amazing food, the friendly staff, and the beautiful decor of the venue!

They also make “Ciao Bella Bottomless Brunches” that also has live entertainment – usually, they invite a DJ, however, sometimes they also have singers, dancers, saxophonist, etc. It’s super interesting and fun to go to one of these brunches (and the food is incredible)!

On their menu, you can find delicious starters (we love the Deep-fried prawn and crab cakes that come with an aioli dip), tasty pizzas and pasta as well as some other traditional dishes.

We highly recommend you get the “Homemade Meat Balls Tagliatelle” – it’s an incredible dish!

Address: 8a Station Parade, Sutton SM2 5AD



Wildwood is a pretty well-known restaurant chain with locations all over the UK – and it just so happens that they have one in Sutton. We really like Wildwood because the food is super tasty and the staff is always friendly! The interior of the restaurant is also incredible – it has that vintage Italian vibe that many restaurants in Italy have!

Wildwood offers tasty starters, burgers, traditional pasta, stonebaked pizzas, risotto, and salads. You need to try their Caesar Salad with chicken (or halloumi or salmon). It has lettuce, egg, anchovies, croutons, cheese, Caesar dressing and it’s truly amazing!

They also have a lot of vegan and vegetarian dishes that are delicious (and can prepare every pizza with vegan cheese)!

Address: 23 The Broadway, Cheam, Sutton SM3 8BH


Mimi e Coco

This family-run restaurant first opened in 2003 – and still manages to offer some of the most delicious pasta in Sutton!

They have fish dishes, meat dishes, pizza, pasta, salads, and amazing desserts so if you do decide to visit Mimi e Coco – you won’t be disappointed!

We often order the Tricolore Salad, their Mushroom Risotto and their Ravioli Al Spinaci E Ricotta (ravioli with spinach and ricotta served with butter and parmesan). We also really enjoy the Pollo Cream Funghi (chicken, cream and mushroom sauce, vegetables and sauté potatoes).

Address: 22A Ewell Rd, Cheam, Sutton SM3 8BU